Does increased intelligence result
in more “mind”? Aside from being contentious, the point I am trying to
illustrate and question here is whether people who are smarter qualify as
human minds more than those of lower intelligence.
Would you be a different person if you were more intelligent? Would you
have the same opinions and personality traits? It goes without saying that an
increase in IQ does cause a change in brain morphology as does simply getting
older. However could this trait be a
scalable measure of our ability to experience and to have qualia?
I was reading an article recently which postulated what life might be
like if everyone were twice as intelligent. For this purpose we shall take that
to mean scoring twice as high on an IQ test. One of
the resulting benefits they discussed might be a greater appreciation for art,
science, music etc. This seems to hint explicitly that appreciation is linked
to understanding. Intelligence by that
fact must equate to more than just computing ability.
Let us ponder what being twice as
smart might actually mean. We would have
an improved ability to assimilate information and learn quicker. People could
learn complex skills like languages and instruments easily and create smarter
solutions to everyday problems. The article suggested that being very
intelligent would result in people living longer. People would have a greater
understanding of what constitutes a healthy lifestyle and be able to look after
themselves more efficiently. However knowledge doesn't always lead to action as
can be seen by people who smoke and take drugs while perfectly aware of their
health risks.
The authors also seem to believe
that behaviour may become more self-serving too. Society wouldn't necessarily become
a glittering utopia run by benevolent geniuses. Crime would become more
advanced with higher stakes and less petty felonies. Religion might also suffer a blow. “God of
the gaps” may disappear completely as we find scientific explanations for
phenomena.
If primitive desires like greed and
anger were still present and powerful in people with sky-high IQ s then it could
be said that emotion and mental processing power are not connected. At least
not beyond a certain level of base-line cognition. Otherwise people who were
more intelligent might develop new emotions.
This doesn't seem to be the case. We all have the same bag of
emotions with which to experience life. And when asking ‘if qualia is a quantifiable
trait?’ we still have no yardstick with which to answer . The most we could say
is that “Red” is still “Red” but a smarter person just gets there faster.
A major problem with this supposition that
the writers of the article have neglected to consider is that difficult as it
may be to imagine “what's it like to be a bat”, imagining
what it is like to be twice as intelligent should also be beyond the realms of
our comprehension. When imagining what increased brain power feels
like we do it through the scope of our much more limited processing abilities. Perhaps time could be spent trying to imagine what it is like to be a computer..
No comments:
Post a Comment